The Church of the Highlands, one of the largest and most influential megachurches in the United States, has gained both admiration and criticism over the years. Led by Pastor Chris Hodges, the Alabama-based church has grown exponentially, with multiple campuses and a massive following. However, with its rapid expansion, several controversies have surfaced, leading critics to question its practices, leadership, and financial transparency.
In this blog post, we will expose some of the key concerns surrounding the Church of the Highlands, including:
- Allegations of Financial Mismanagement
- Controversial Leadership Decisions
- Criticism Over Cult-Like Practices
- Political and Social Controversies
- Responses from the Church and Supporters
By the end of this article, you’ll have a clearer understanding of why some people are raising red flags about this megachurch.
1. Allegations of Financial Mismanagement
One of the biggest concerns critics have about the Church of the Highlands is its financial transparency—or lack thereof. Like many megachurches, it operates on a massive budget, reportedly bringing in tens of millions of dollars annually in tithes and donations.
Where Does the Money Go?
- Pastor Salaries & Lavish Spending – While the exact salary of Pastor Chris Hodges is not publicly disclosed (as the church is not required to file IRS Form 990), critics speculate that top leaders earn substantial incomes. Some former members claim that funds are used for luxury expenses, including private jets and high-end real estate.
- Property Investments – The church owns multiple high-value properties, including a $28 million campus in Grants Mill, Alabama. Some argue that such spending prioritizes expansion over community aid.
- Lack of Transparency – Unlike nonprofits that disclose financial records, megachurches often avoid detailed public reports, raising suspicions about fund allocation.
Comparison to Other Megachurch Scandals
Financial controversies are not unique to the Church of the Highlands. Other megachurches, like Joel Osteen’s Lakewood Church and Creflo Dollar’s World Changers, have faced similar scrutiny over lavish spending and lack of accountability.
2. Controversial Leadership Decisions
Another area of concern is the church’s leadership structure and decision-making. Some former members and critics accuse the church of authoritarian leadership, where dissent is discouraged.
Key Leadership Issues
- Pastor Chris Hodges’ Controversial Statements – Hodges faced backlash in 2020 for liking a tweet that compared Black Lives Matter to a “false religion.” Though he later apologized, the incident raised questions about racial sensitivity within the church.
- Handling of Member Complaints – Some ex-members claim that concerns about doctrine or leadership were dismissed, with critics being labeled as “divisive” or “rebellious.”
- Lack of Denominational Oversight – As a nondenominational church, Highlands operates independently, meaning there’s no external board holding leadership accountable.
The “Celebrity Pastor” Problem
Critics argue that Hodges, like many megachurch pastors, has become a celebrity figure, with followers treating his teachings as unquestionable. This dynamic can lead to a lack of accountability.
3. Criticism Over Cult-Like Practices
Some former members and watchdog groups have accused the Church of the Highlands of exhibiting cult-like tendencies, including:
Isolation from Outside Influence
- Discouraging Critical Thinking – Some ex-members report being told to avoid “negative” outside sources, including news outlets and other churches.
- Emphasis on Loyalty – The church promotes absolute commitment, with some feeling pressured to prioritize church activities over personal relationships.
Small Group Dynamics
The church heavily promotes small groups, which some say function as echo chambers where dissent is suppressed. Former members describe feeling guilt-tripped into deeper involvement.
Comparisons to Other Controversial Churches
Similar accusations have been made against churches like Bethel Church in California and Hillsong, where intense discipleship models sometimes blur the line between devotion and control.
4. Political and Social Controversies
The Church of the Highlands has also faced scrutiny over its political and social stances.
BLM and Racial Justice Backlash
As mentioned earlier, Hodges’ 2020 Twitter controversy damaged the church’s reputation among progressive Christians. Some Black congregants left, feeling the church was not supportive of racial justice efforts.
Affiliation with Controversial Figures
- Links to Donald Trump – Hodges has been photographed with Trump, leading some to believe the church leans heavily conservative.
- Ties to the NAR (New Apostolic Reformation) – Some researchers link Highlands to this controversial movement, which promotes dominion theology (the idea that Christians should take over societal institutions).
LGBTQ+ Stance
Like many evangelical churches, Highlands holds a traditional view on LGBTQ+ issues, which has alienated some progressive believers.
5. Responses from the Church and Supporters
Despite these controversies, the Church of the Highlands maintains a strong following. Supporters argue:
- The church does extensive charity work, including food drives and addiction recovery programs.
- Many members report life-changing experiences through its ministries.
- Hodges’ apologies and adjustments show a willingness to grow.
However, critics say good works don’t excuse lack of transparency or accountability.
Final Thoughts: Should You Be Concerned?
The Church of the Highlands is not alone in facing these criticisms—many megachurches struggle with similar issues. The key takeaways are:
Financial Transparency Matters – Donors deserve to know how funds are used.
Healthy Churches Welcome Accountability – Leadership should be open to critique.
Community Impact vs. Expansion – Is growth prioritized over genuine discipleship?
If you’re a member or considering joining, research thoroughly, ask questions, and stay informed.
